Sanibel Island Hotels

Hotels Find

List of best hotels

Sanibel Island Hotels

Check Availability

Sanibel
Dec 01, 2025 - Dec 02, 2025
Find

Are you in a hurry?

Here is a quick list of Hotels in Sanibel, selected based on their rating

Name of hotel Accommodation Rating Price, $
Island Inn

9.0 / 10

(102 Reviews)

From 689$
Sanibel Island Beach Resort

8.2 / 10

(347 Reviews)

From 253$
Sundial Beach Resort & Spa

7.9 / 10

(18 Reviews)

From 192$
Sanibel Arms West Hotel

9.1 / 10

(148 Reviews)

From 321$
Sanibel Inn

9.1 / 10

(90 Reviews)

From 202$

Sanibel Best Hotels

Navigation

1. Island Inn

2. Sanibel Island Beach Resort

3. Sundial Beach Resort & Spa

4. Sanibel Arms West Hotel

5. Sanibel Inn

6. Sunshine Island Inn - Adults Only

7. Anchor Inn And Cottages

8. West Wind Inn

9. Song Of The Sea Hotel

10. Gulf Breeze Cottages

Island Inn

5+
View all photos

Located a 10-minute ride from the inhabited Sanibel Island, the 3-star Island Inn Sanibel features a picnic area, a community pool, and a shuffleboard court. Traditions On the Beach is only 50 metres from here.

The property is situated 5 km from Sanibel city centre and 40 km from Page Field airport. Guests can enjoy the own beach where sunbeds and parasols are provided. You can get to Bailey's General Store in a few minutes by car.

📍 Address: 3111 West Gulf Drive
✔️ Rating: Excellent 9 (102 Reviews)
🔑 Rooms: 20
🏷️ Price: From 689$

Sanibel Island Beach Resort

7+
View all photos

Sanibel Island Beach Resort enjoys a tranquil location in Sanibel and features an outdoor pool and a garden. It is 4.7 km from Sanibel Captiva Conservation Foundation and 2.2 km from Gulfside Beach.

Located off Sanibel Island Golf Club, the inn is about 15 minutesโ€™ walk from Sanibel city centre. The nearby tropical beach with sunbeds and plush towels is available for guests' relaxation. Sanibel Island Beach Resort is a short ride from Sanibel Historical Museum and Village. Page Field airport can be reached in just a 37-minute drive.

📍 Address: 1231 Middle Gulf Drive
✔️ Rating: Very good 8.2 (347 Reviews)
🔑 Rooms: 99
🏷️ Price: From 253$

Sundial Beach Resort & Spa

7+
View all photos

Sundial Beach Resort & Spa Sanibel, located 10 minutes' drive from Bailey's General Store, boasts a swimming pool. The venue is situated 1 km from Sanibel city centre and 35 km from Page Field airport.

The accommodation is located a 10-minute ride from Sanibel Causeway. You can get to Lighthouse Beach Park in a few minutes by car.

📍 Address: 1451 Middle Gulf Drive
✔️ Rating: Very good 7.9 (18 Reviews)
🔑 Rooms: 65
🏷️ Price: From 192$

Sanibel Arms West Hotel

7+
View all photos

Sanibel Arms West Hotel, set 10 minutes by car from Lighthouse Beach Park, offers a swimming pool as well as a tennis centre. The venue is located off Sanibel Moorings Botanical Gardens, just 20 minutes' walk from the city centre.

The accommodation is 15 minutes' drive from The Bailey-Matthews National Shell Museum. There is easy access to the own beach. You can get to The Dunes in a few minutes by car.

📍 Address: 827 East Gulf Drive
✔️ Rating: Excellent 9.1 (148 Reviews)
🔑 Rooms: 104
🏷️ Price: From 321$

Sanibel Inn

7+
View all photos

Sanibel Inn is located in Sanibel and offers 3-star accommodation with a swimming pool and a tennis club. The historic beacon "Sanibel Island Lighthouse" is a 10-minute drive away and Periwinkle Way is 25 minutes' walk from the venue.

The hotel is situated 2 km from Sanibel city centre and 30 km from Page Field airport. The nearby white sand beach with sunbeds, beach umbrellas, and soft towels is available for guests' relaxation. The inn is perfectly located near Sanibel Moorings Botanical Gardens.

📍 Address: 937 East Gulf Drive
✔️ Rating: Excellent 9.1 (90 Reviews)
🔑 Rooms: 71
🏷️ Price: From 202$

Sunshine Island Inn - Adults Only

4+
View all photos

Featuring a swimming pool, Sunshine Island Inn - Adults Only Sanibel is only 1.7 km from Periwinkle Way. The venue is located along private beach, about 2 km from the centre of Sanibel.

The accommodation is about a 10-minute drive from Lighthouse Beach Park. Sanibel Moorings Botanical Gardens is not far away. Sunshine Island Inn - Adults Only lies 35 km from Page Field airport.

📍 Address: 642 East Gulf Drive
✔️ Rating: Excellent 9.5 (145 Reviews)
🔑 Rooms: 6
🏷️ Price: From 129$

Anchor Inn And Cottages

5+
View all photos

The affordable Anchor Inn And Cottages is 20 minutes on foot from Shipley Trail Parking in Sanibel. The property provides 12 guestrooms appointed with an adjoining terrace, a sofa set, and coffee and tea making equipment for a pleasant stay in Sanibel.

The centre of Sanibel can be reached within a 20-minute walk. Sanibel Public Library is 5 minutes' drive from the holiday park in Sanibel. Anchor Inn And Cottages is a short ride from Sanibel Historical Museum and Village. The nearest airport is Page Field, located 30 km from the property.

📍 Address: 1245 Periwinkle Way
✔️ Rating: Very good 8.2 (391 Reviews)
🔑 Rooms: 12
🏷️ Price: From 142$

West Wind Inn

3+
View all photos

The 3-star West Wind Inn Sanibel is within a 10-minute drive of The Bailey-Matthews National Shell Museum. This inn features a community pool and a golf course as well as Wi-Fi throughout the property.

The property is situated 5 km from Sanibel city centre and 40 km from Page Field airport. USS Mohawk CGC Veterans Memorial Reef is a short walk away, while Sanibel Island is at a 2.4 km distance. You can get to Clinic for the Rehabilitation of Wildlife Education Center in a few minutes by car.

📍 Address: 3345 West Gulf Drive
✔️ Rating: Excellent 8.6 (271 Reviews)
🔑 Rooms: 103
🏷️ Price: From 271$

Song Of The Sea Hotel

7+
View all photos

Located 2.1 km from Periwinkle Way, guests of 3-star Song Of The Sea Hotel Sanibel may find a hot tub and an outdoor swimming pool on-site. The venue is situated 2 km from Sanibel city centre and 30 km from Page Field airport.

The Bailey-Matthews National Shell Museum is less than 6 km away. Nearby attractions include Sanibel Moorings Botanical Gardens.

📍 Address: 863 East Gulf Drive
✔️ Rating: Excellent 8.6 (371 Reviews)
🔑 Rooms: 30
🏷️ Price: From 329$

Gulf Breeze Cottages

3+
View all photos

Gulf Breeze Cottages Sanibel is a 2-star venue situated within 10 minutes' drive of the historic beacon "Sanibel Island Lighthouse". Guests will have access to a car park on site for added convenience.

The accommodation lies about 20 minutes' walk from the city centre. Ladyfinger Lake is a 10-minute ride from the holiday park in Sanibel. Gulf Breeze Cottages is a short ride from Sanibel Causeway. Page Field airport is situated nearly 30 km away.

📍 Address: 1081 Shell Basket Lane
✔️ Rating: Excellent 9 (106 Reviews)
🔑 Rooms: 13
🏷️ Price: From 259$

Seahorse Cottages - Adults Only

4+
View all photos

Seahorse Cottages - Adults Only Sanibel is a 3-star venue 12 minutes' stroll from Sanibel Island Lighthouse. Offering views of the garden, the accommodation is placed close to Periwinkle Way and boasts a swimming pool.

Sanibel centre can be reached within 5 minutes' walk. Sanibel Island Northern Beach is 0.6 km from the inn, while Page Field airport is 35 km from it. Seahorse Cottages - Adults Only is a short ride from Ladyfinger Lake.

📍 Address: 1223 Buttonwood Lane
✔️ Rating: Excellent 9.4 (124 Reviews)
🏷️ Price: From 478$

Location